How Much Equity Should You Give Early Employees? A Guide to Structuring Your Startup’s Cap Table to Fuel Growth and Attract Investors

Building a Solid Foundation: Essential Guide to Structuring Equity  for Startups

Starting a business is exciting, but one of the early decisions that can significantly impact a startup's future is figuring out how much equity to give early employees and structuring the cap table. The cap table, which documents the distribution of ownership, often determines the company's ability to grow smoothly and attract future investors. This guide provides insights for founders on how to approach equity distribution, manage vesting, and create a cap table that aligns with long-term growth goals.

Why Is Cap Table Management So Important for Startups?

Creating a cap table for your startup is more than just distributing shares—it’s about setting a strong foundation. A well-thought-out cap table can make a startup attractive to investors, simplify future funding rounds, and motivate the founding team to drive toward a common goal. However, a poorly structured cap table can lead to internal conflict, lack of motivation, or even scare off potential investors.

At Interplay, we often see early-stage founders struggle with questions about equity, ownership, and future dilution. With this guide, we aim to clarify some of these complex topics and help you build a cap table that positions your company for success.

How Should Founders Think About Initial Equity Splits?

Equity splits among founders should ideally reflect the commitment and value each person brings to the startup. Equal splits make sense if all founders contribute equally in terms of skills, experience, and time investment. However, unequal splits are also common, especially if one founder brings critical expertise, initial capital, or has a significant leadership role.

Key points to consider:

1. Contribution and Commitment: Weigh each founder’s contribution to ensure everyone has a stake that motivates them to stay committed.
2. Long-Term Vision: Align equity splits with the long-term vision to prevent future disputes.
3. Clear Conversations: Discuss roles, contributions, and commitments early on to avoid misunderstandings down the road.

What Is Vesting, and Why Is It Essential?

Vesting is a mechanism that aligns long-term commitment by gradually granting equity over time. Most startups adopt a four-year vesting schedule with a one-year cliff, where team members earn ownership gradually, incentivizing them to stay involved.

Common Vesting Schedules:

• Four-Year Vesting with a One-Year Cliff: Team members earn shares over four years, with the first 25% vesting after the first year.
• Longer Vesting for Key Founders: For founders with significant equity, a six- to ten-year vesting period may be more suitable, aligning with their deeper commitment to the company.

Note: While this four-year vesting norm is standard, remember that it was established during a time when companies went public within four years. Now, IPO timelines have lengthened, making it wise to consider vesting structures that better match today’s longer growth cycles.

How Should You Structure the Cap Table?

Founders, investors, employees, and advisors are common players in a cap table. Structuring ownership early on with a thoughtful approach can prevent issues later. Here’s a general breakdown for early-stage companies:

1. Founders: Typically, founders collectively hold 60-70% of the initial equity.
2. Employee Option Pool: Reserving 10-20% for employee options is common. This pool allows for attracting talent, especially in crucial early roles.
3. Investors and Advisors: Setting aside around 20% for early investors and advisors can help fund the company’s early growth and support strategic development.

An option pool serves as a “phantom” stock allocation for future hires, indicating to investors and potential hires that the company is planning for growth.

How Much Should You Allocate to Key Early Employees?

Early employees are often offered a small but meaningful equity stake, often within the range of 0.5% to 2%, depending on their role. This percentage decreases over time with each round of funding and as the company grows. Offering significant ownership to early hires ensures they’re invested in the company’s success and helps attract top talent who might otherwise be drawn to established firms.

Guidelines for Equity Distribution:

• Key Hires (VP Level or Above): Consider offering 0.5-2% equity, depending on their critical role.
• Early Engineers and Specialists: Generally receive around 0.1-1%, which reflects their contribution to the startup’s growth.

What Role Does Dilution Play in Equity Management?

As startups raise more capital, shares are typically issued to new investors, which can dilute existing shareholders' ownership. However, if the funding round increases the startup’s value, dilution is often more than offset by the increased valuation. In other words, while each founder’s percentage might decrease, the overall value of their shares can increase.

Pro Tip: When setting up your cap table, plan for future dilution. For instance, establishing an employee option pool can help ensure you have enough shares to offer new hires without disproportionately diluting current shareholders.

FAQs: Common Questions About Cap Table and Equity Management

What should a startup cap table include?
A cap table typically includes founders, investors, an option pool for employees, and advisors. It tracks share ownership and helps visualize dilution during future funding rounds.

What is a cliff in vesting schedules?
A cliff is a time period at the beginning of a vesting schedule (often one year) during which equity doesn’t vest. After this period, a chunk of equity (usually 25%) vests all at once, with the remainder vesting monthly. A cliff prevents equity from going to team members who leave shortly after joining.

How should I decide on my startup’s vesting schedule?
Four years with a one-year cliff is the standard for most startups. However, if your business requires a longer runway, consider a six- or ten-year vesting schedule to ensure alignment over time, especially for founders and key early hires.

Is it necessary to have an employee option pool?
An option pool signals to investors that your company is planning to scale, attracting quality hires by offering equity. Though not mandatory, it’s generally recommended for early-stage startups. The percentage you allocate (typically 10-20%) depends on projected hiring needs.

How does dilution affect my ownership?
Dilution reduces the ownership percentage of existing shareholders when new shares are issued. However, if the new capital drives the company’s value higher, the absolute value of your shares may increase despite the lower percentage.

Ready to learn more about startup equity and cap tables? Listen to more episodes of Innovation with Mark Peter Davis to stay informed and get expert insights on building your startup with confidence.

Looking for hands-on support for your growing business? Check out our Interplay Incubator for resources, mentorship, and a strong network to guide you on the journey.

‍